After having heard a lot about how nice the Giants’ new park in San Francisco is, I finally got down there.
I’m…. underwhelmed.
Don’t get me wrong- it’s a really cool park. I love how it sits right on the water and how the fence comes in from CF to the right field foul pole, and the kayakers hoping for HR balls in the water beyond.
I also really like how they designed it so that the vast majority of the seats in the upper decks have a nice view of the water. That’s cool.
The design choices they made are cool, too- very much like Safeco Field, with lots of brick and nice dark-green-painted steel girders and structural supports.
But we went on a little walkabout around the whole stadium, and some parts of it were fairly lame. The concourses were actually pretty bad- quite narrow and crowded, far worse than Safeco’s gets. We were at a game that started at 6 so perhaps it’s worse than normal with a lot of people ordering food at the park, but man, those walkways were really small and really jammed.
When you come through the RF walkway there’s one part where it’s so narrow I’m surprised it met codes.
And those concourses are just too… busy. With color. Everywhere you look, there’s signs and advertisements (and I mean EVERYWHERE) and they’re all in garish colors (granted, the Giants primary color is orange, so you’re going to see a ton of that) and there’s just too much stuff that’s too cute by about half.
Instead of looking old-school advertisingish, it just looks like someone with ADHD went off and put up signs willy-nilly.
The seats were okay. One thing I liked was that the second deck hangs low over the 100 level. Some people don’t like it because from the concourse it cuts off your view a bit, but I liked it because it means those seats are pretty good seats. They also continue all the way around behind home plate, where at Safeco the spot directly behind home is taken up by the giant press box.
On the downside, those seats range in price from $68 to $85 a game! Holy overpricing, Batman! At Safeco they range from $65 to 70 for individual game pricing, and are just $45 if you buy them as season tickets.
In fact, every “premium” seat at AT&T costs considerably more than its counterpart in Safeco. In the Giants’ defense, they financed their park themselves; I’m not sure about land costs but I know that the actual construction was pretty much all privately paid for by the ownership group. So in a way, I can handle them charging it- it’s their gig, they can do what they want.
And the upper deck seats are priced much closer to Safeco’s. They’re a bit closer to the field, but they’re also a bit higher off the ground, so it’s kind of a wash there.
All in all, I wonder if maybe my impression of AT&T was influenced by the weather. August 1st and it was about 55 degrees, breezy, and with a leeeetle bit of mist/drizzle falling. Ginger and I earlier were walking around town (we walked from our hotel at Union Square Park through Chinatown to North Beach for some food, then back to the hotel and then down to the ballpark) and got a bit chilly. Then again, that’s just San Francisco for you, I guess.
Oh, that reminds me- AT&T park is a bit of a hike from much of anything. From our hotel to the park felt like it was roughly equivalent in distance as from walking all the way down from Belltown to Safeco (I know I’m comparing it to Seattle a lot, but that’s what I know best so that’s why I use that as a comparison) except that from Belltown to Safeco, you go through areas that have stuff going on and the park is right on the edge of Pioneer Square.
In SF, you’re walking through a heck of a lot of nothing. It seems like the area is going to recover, but right now there’s not a lot of anything distinctive there.
Maybe on a bright sunny day with mid-70s I’d like AT&T Park better, but right now, I don’t think so. It’s a great park, way better than a lot of the older-school parks out there (and FAR better than Candlestick), but given the choice I’ll stick with Safeco Field.